Independence: Notre Dame Football's Uniqueness -

By Eric Boggs from The OHIO Podcast

When it comes to college football, few teams boast a legacy as storied and revered as the Fighting Irish of Notre Dame. Yet, beyond touchdowns and trophies, lies a fundamental aspect that sets them apart: independence.

For decades, Notre Dame has chosen to stand alone, unaffiliated with any conference. While other teams find strength in numbers, the Fighting Irish have forged their path, and their reasons for eschewing conference membership run deep.

Many don’t know the origins of Notre Dame’s independence, or why they hold onto that tradition in the same regard as Ohio State fans do dotting the “I” in Script Ohio, or the phrase, “War Eagle,” to an Auburn fan.

At the heart of Notre Dame’s independence is a story that goes all the way back to the early 1900’s. In 1909, Notre Dame defeated Michigan. The Wolverines coach at the time, Fielding Yost, who had the reputation of winning at all cost, was so angered in defeat, that he spit venom at the media following the game. Yost, who was the son of a Confederate office from West Virginia, had a notable distain for losing, blacks, and Catholics. Following that defeat, Yost refused to schedule Notre Dame ever again, which meant that the Irish didn’t get a chance to play Michigan, who was the most dominate team in the Midwest, until 1942.

This ego and racist fueled decision by Yost forced Notre Dame to schedule opponents across the country. Doing so gave Notre Dame the opportunity to expose themselves to more fans, thus creating a fanbase of immigrants and Catholics from coast to coast. Despite Yost’s personal feelings and attempt to “hurt” his opponent to the south, this decision aided the Irish program in creating the nation’s first ever coast to coast fanbase, that they charmingly call the Subway Alumni.

Notre Dame’s starch Catholic roots, it’s belief in offering immigrants an opportunity to higher learning, and their historical perseverance in the face of racism, birthed a value system that was unique. It spoke to many Americans, creating college football’s first ever fanbase that had little to do with geography. It also gave birth to the spirit of independence.

Preserving that independence to many Notre Dame fan’s is no different than the other values they hold dear. To some, independence is just a much a factor of being a Notre Dame fan as is being Catholic, or holding dear the roots of one’s family immigrant heritage.

“Being independent allows us to honor our history and maintain our unique brand,” explained former Notre Dame Head Coach Brian Kelly. “It’s about more than just football; it’s about what Notre Dame represents.”

Indeed, the Fighting Irish are more than a football team; they are an institution steeped in tradition. From the echoes of Knute Rockne’s legendary speeches to the iconic golden helmets gleaming under the stadium lights, every aspect of Notre Dame football is a testament to its heritage.

Moreover, independence affords Notre Dame unparalleled flexibility and exposure. By scheduling games with teams from across the country, the Fighting Irish can showcase their talents on a national stage. From the historic rivalry with USC to matchups against powerhouses like Alabama and Ohio State, Notre Dame’s schedule is a testament to their commitment to facing top competition.

But perhaps the most compelling reason for Notre Dame’s independence is the freedom it provides in shaping their destiny. While conference affiliations come with rules and regulations, the Fighting Irish have the autonomy to chart their course, both on and off the field.

“Independence gives us the flexibility to pursue our goals without constraints,” stated former Athletic Director Jack Swarbrick. “Whether it’s recruiting top talent or making decisions about our program, we have the freedom to do what’s best for Notre Dame.”

However, the decision to remain independent is not without its critics. Some argue that joining a conference would provide Notre Dame with a clearer path to the College Football Playoff and increase revenue opportunities. Yet, for the Fighting Irish, success is not measured solely in wins and losses but in the values they uphold and the legacy they leave behind.

For Notre Dame, independence is not just a choice; it’s a tradition. From the hallowed halls of Notre Dame Stadium to the hearts of fans around the world, the Fighting Irish will continue to stand tall, charting their course with pride and purpose. For in the game of life, true greatness lies in staying true to oneself, no matter the odds.